What Actually Leads Employees to Healthier Behaviors

If you think it's giving them more money, think again.

Author

Nicholas Layne
August 17, 2026

Welcome to the Well-being Wire, the bi-weekly newsletter focused on practical strategies and solutions that advance well-being in the workplace.

Here's a controversial statement:

Incentives don’t lead your employees to create healthy habits.

Your incentive design does.

When participation is lower than expected, the first reaction is often to increase the reward and offer more money.

But behavioral economics suggests that motivation is more complicated than that.

Research consistently shows that timing, emotion, simplicity, and social influence can be just as important as the reward itself.

In fact, some of the strongest behavioral outcomes come from incentives that create immediate reinforcement.

Why?

Because humans are wired to respond more strongly to rewards they can experience now rather than benefits they might receive months later.

But there's another lesson organizations often miss.

People are strategic.

If employees believe today's performance will simply create a harder target tomorrow, they may intentionally hold back.

Behavioral economists call this gaming the system.

And it's one reason poorly designed incentive programs can actually reduce performance over time.

The best incentive systems don't just reward outcomes.

They remove friction.

They reinforce behavior quickly.

They create emotional engagement.

And they make progress feel visible.

Removing friction means making the desired healthy behavior easier to start, easier to repeat, and less dependent on willpower.

Reinforcing behavior quickly means recognizing positive actions soon after they happen so people connect the behavior with a sense of progress or reward.

Creating emotional engagement means helping people see the behavior as personally meaningful, tied to their identity, values, family, team, or future self.

Making progress visible means showing people that their effort is adding up, even when the bigger health outcome may take longer to appear.

The most effective programs aren't built around bigger rewards.

They're built around better behavioral design.

Share the knowledge! If you know someone who needs these insights, forward this newsletter and make their program better (and if someone already forwarded you this, click here to subscribe for future issues 🙂).

Want more? Check out our full library of past issues here.

An example of a fully customized well-being portal designed by Propel

At Propel, we create made from scratch well-being platforms that are built to fit your brand, goals, voice, initiatives, and culture.

Propel partners with our clients by providing a dedicated team that works collaboratively on a weekly basis to develop a program plan, set metrics, create custom branded communication and marketing materials, plan and implement engagement initiatives, answer questions, and provide strategic advice.

From marketing and communication strategy and execution to well-being champions programming, we design your program (not ours).

If you believe there is value in a well-being program that truly integrates your organizational culture but need strategic guidance or a team to take the workload on for you, Propel would love to help. The easiest way to get started is by scheduling a strategy session with us to discuss your program.